Why Most Kiwi Businesses Get SEO Content Completely Wrong

Learn more about Told Agency's innovative approach to SEO-infused storytelling

The average NZ website is a graveyard of content nobody reads.

Bloated "about us" pages that say nothing. Blog posts that haven't been updated since 2019. Service pages packed with industry jargon no actual human would ever search for.

And then business owners wonder why they're invisible online.

Here's the cold, hard truth: most Kiwi businesses approach content like it's 2010 - write some keywords-stuffed blogs, pray to the Google gods, and hope for the best.

But the rules have changed. The algorithm has evolved. And your competitors are already adapting.

The Great Content Paradox

Here's the fundamental tension that trips up most NZ businesses:

Content that ranks well often reads like it was written by a robot.Content that engages humans often gets buried on page 7 of Google.

This leaves businesses with an impossible choice: write for algorithms or write for people?

Spoiler alert: you need to do both. But not in the way you think.

Why Your SEO Content Strategy is Failing

Before we get to the solution, let's diagnose where most Kiwi businesses go wrong:

1. Starting with keywords instead of customer problems

Most businesses approach content backwards. They find keywords with decent search volume and then force content around them.

This gives you technically "optimised" content that nobody actually wants to read.

Real people don't search for "affordable Wellington accountant services." They search for "how to reduce my tax bill" or "do I need to register for GST?"

2. Outsourcing to the lowest bidder

That $50 blog post you commissioned from an offshore content mill? Yeah, Google can tell.

AI content detection is built into the algorithm now. Generic, shallow content written without genuine expertise doesn't just bore your readers – it actively hurts your rankings.

3. Confusing quantity with strategy

"We need to blog more!" is not a strategy.

Publishing 20 mediocre blog posts will never outperform five genuinely helpful, in-depth pieces that actually solve customer problems.

The Jobs-to-be-Done Approach to SEO Content

Remember our discussion about Jobs-to-be-Done? It's the perfect framework for creating content that both ranks and resonates.

Here's how to apply it:

Step 1: Identify the "jobs" your customers are hiring search engines to do

When someone types a query into Google, they're not just looking for information – they're trying to accomplish something specific.

For example, someone searching "best mortgage rates NZ" isn't just comparison shopping. They might be:

  • Trying to determine if they can afford to buy right now
  • Looking for ammunition to negotiate with their current bank
  • Seeking reassurance they're not getting ripped off

Understanding these underlying jobs changes how you create content.

Step 2: Map search intent to customer journey stages

Different searches indicate different stages in the customer journey:

Information stage: "How does a heat pump work in winter?"Evaluation stage: "Mitsubishi vs Daikin heat pump comparison"Decision stage: "Heat pump installation Christchurch reviews"

Your content strategy needs pieces that address each stage, not just the bottom-of-funnel keywords that directly mention your product or service.

Step 3: Build content that does two jobs simultaneously

Here's where the magic happens. Each piece of content should:

  1. Satisfy the user's immediate search need (the information they want)
  2. Move them closer to choosing your business (the outcome you want)

The  Framework for Content That Ranks AND Converts

1. Problem/Solution Validation

Before writing a single word, validate that:

  • The problem exists (sufficient search volume)
  • You have a legitimate solution (actual expertise)
  • There's a path to conversion (clear next steps)

2. Expert-Driven Creation

Content should be created by people who genuinely understand the topic and the audience. This might mean:

  • Interviewing your technical team
  • Drawing on case studies and client experiences
  • Bringing your unique perspective to common questions

Google's helpful content update explicitly rewards content with "first-hand expertise." Generic, surface-level content gets penalised.

3. Structured for Both Humans and Algorithms

The best content satisfies both masters:

For humans:

  • Clear, conversational language
  • Scannable structure with descriptive headings
  • Specific examples and practical advice
  • Visual elements that enhance understanding

For algorithms:

  • Strategic keyword placement in key positions
  • Comprehensive coverage of related subtopics
  • Schema markup for enhanced SERP features
  • Proper internal linking to related content

4. Multimedia Enhancement

Text alone isn't enough anymore. The most successful content incorporates:

  • Original images and diagrams
  • Video explanations of complex concepts
  • Interactive elements where appropriate
  • Audio versions for accessibility

5. Conversion Pathways

Every piece of content should have clear next steps based on search intent:

  • Information seekers → Related, deeper content
  • Evaluation seekers → Comparison tools or case studies
  • Decision seekers → Frictionless contact options

Common Objections (And Why They're Wrong)

"Our industry is too boring for engaging content"

There are no boring industries, only boring approaches. The more "boring" your industry, the bigger the opportunity to stand out with genuinely helpful, human content.

"We tried blogging before and it didn't work"

If your previous efforts didn't drive results, you were likely creating the wrong content, for the wrong audience, with the wrong strategy. Content without strategy is just digital clutter.

The Future of SEO Content for NZ Businesses

Looking ahead, here's what will separate winners from losers in the content game:

AI Integration (The Right Way)

AI tools won't replace human expertise, but they will amplify it. Smart businesses will use AI to:

  • Generate initial outlines based on topic research
  • Identify content gaps in existing material
  • Create personalized content experiences at scale
  • Enhance (not replace) human creativity

Topic Ownership vs. Keyword Targeting

The future belongs to businesses that own entire topic areas, not just individual keywords. This means building comprehensive content hubs that answer every question a potential customer might have about a subject.

User Signals as the Ultimate Ranking Factor

Google is increasingly looking at how users interact with your content. Do they find what they need? Do they stay engaged? Do they continue their journey on your site? These behavioral signals will matter more than technical SEO tactics.

The Last Word: From Content Marketing to Company-Wide Content Strategy

The most successful Kiwi businesses won't view content as a marketing function – they'll see it as a business-wide strategic asset.

Sales teams will contribute insights from customer conversations.Product teams will share their expertise.Customer service will highlight common questions and concerns.

Every person in your organization has valuable knowledge that could become your next highest-performing content piece.

The question is: are you capturing that knowledge and turning it into assets that work for your business 24/7?

If not, you're leaving money on the table and handing an advantage to competitors who understand that in today's digital landscape, helpful content isn't just nice to have – it's essential for survival and growth.

Ready to transform your approach to content? Let's talk about how the Jobs-to-be-Done framework can revolutionize both your rankings and your results.

Contact Us

Other blog posts

see all blogs